Artist as Other Artist
Saul Bellow’s son, a writer too, once explained how over the years he had incorporated aspects of his late father’s being into himself: “ways of thinking, particular expressions, a certain way of looking at the world.” Now that he was dead, he wrote, “my father, though absent, is deeply, unpredictably, stubbornly present in me.”1 Poetic painters feel the same way about earlier masters whose work they have studied so intently that the other artist’s characteristics, brushstrokes, subject matter and ways of thinking are deeply embedded in themselves. This means that Giorgio Vasari’s account of how the soul of one Renaissance artist was kept alive in the next is not a mere literary flourish (as generally explained) but a very accurate description of how one artist feels about another. This deep sense of identification with their earlier peers can be seen in art from many periods and many countries.
When Matisse and Picasso discussed the issue in old age, they both agreed that it was important to keep earlier artists “alive in their minds.”2 Indeed Picasso, on being shown some Paleolithic cave art, wondered whether he might not even have been that cave-painter, “the same little man” reborn time and again as a great artist until he became Picasso. Awareness of this theme and of its importance to poets will help you recognize such references in the most unlikely places. Indeed the ways in which artists weave this meaning are varied, with some of the more common ones demonstrated below. Become familiar with them because the more often you see them (as with any theme here), the more often and easily you will recognize them elsewhere.
1. Adam Bellow, “Missing My Father”, New York Times, June 10th 2005, p. A21
2. Françoise Gilot, Matisse and Picasso: A Friendship in Art (New York: Doubleday) 1990, p.90
Most Recent Articles
Artists often identify with other artists, using them as an alter ego. Here is an exceptionally clever one.
All Articles (Alphabetical by Artist, then Title)
In a short addendum to Part 1, see how Balthus conveyed his alter ego
See how Basquiat's Boone turns facial resemblance on its head and becomes Basquiat.
"Mistakes" in representing reality are cues to the scene's underlying meaning
A long-mysterious image succumbs to interpretation if seen through a different paradigm
Cranach saw a resemblance in someone else's work and made it his own, a common practice in poetic art
Not everything about this self-portrait is quite as obvious as it seems
See how one form can metamorphose into another while bringing with it the form's original meaning
If you can't make a sense of an image beyond what it appears to be, keep looking until you can. Come back to it, time and again, until you do.
See what Degas makes of a Delacroix and thus, perhaps, what you should too....
Find out how a little knowledge of studio life goes a long way
Learn how an artist can link himself through music to great painters before him
See how a classical legend becomes the perfect setting for an allegory on the artist's studio
Don't confuse illusion with likeness in portraits; they are different
Why would a great master when copying a portrait by an earlier master change the features of the portrait sitter?
How an artist, the artist's lover, is Ingres' own androgynous reflection
The universal features of Frida Kahlo's art are what links her to the canon, not the details of her private life
An obvious example of how later artists can see in an artist's work what we, ordinary viewers, do not.
This early painting by Manet has always troubled interpreters because it seems to make no apparent sense. Its explanation here, though, will help you understand paintings by Manet, Velazquez and other artists too.
Learn something about Manet's first major painting that has never been noted, except by artists.
One of the many ways artists "paint themselves" is by painting others as earlier great masters.
See how Manet identifies with a female artist of his own acquaintance, probably without her even knowing
Everyone knows that Boating is a masterpiece. Why is it so difficult to explain?
Léon Leenhof, Manet's young son, is posed in this print as though he is selecting paint from his tray (palette) and is about to apply it to the sheet of paper we are looking at.
Artists do not have to use their own features in a portrait of someone else. There are other ways of identifying with the sitter as Manet demonstrates in this portrait.
Find out how Manet's observations of scenes in Parisian cafés are really something else entirely
A wonderful example of how blind anyone can be using the wrong form of visual perception
Find out how the viewer in this garden scene is really inside Manet's mind
See how Manet's identification with Courbet is recognized by a later artist who then used it in his portrait of yet another artist.
Learn how one artist shows their identification with another
Skating on ice is like drawing lines on the mirrored surface of the artist's mind
Once you know what to look for, Manet's tricks are obvious
See how smoke and mirrors turn the outside of Manet's studio into the inside
This magical composition hides a complex thought of seeming effortless construction: a masterpiece of the first order
There is more to the Tragic Actor than meets the eye. Find out what's there that others cannot see.
See how Matisse's identification with an earlier artist is conveyed in a businessman's portrait
© Simon Abrahams. Articles on this site are the copyright of Simon Abrahams. To use copyrighted material in print or other media for purposes beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. Websites may link to this page without permission (please do) but may not reproduce the material on their own site without crediting Simon Abrahams and EPPH.